Learning High Probability Selling from ChatGPT: An Experiment

I opened ChatGPT in a private browser window without signing in, so that it would have no access to my previous conversations with my own instance of ChatGPT. I wanted to see what someone unfamiliar with HPS might learn by asking their own ChatGPT about it. After several exchanges, I explained my purpose and I then asked that ChatGPT to summarize our conversation. What follows is its response to my request. Note that it identified itself in third person. My two modifications to its response are enclosed in square brackets []. Everything else below was written by that ChatGPT.


What [an ordinary untrained] ChatGPT Understands About High Probability Selling

This conversation began with a simple question [asked by Carl Ingalls]: “What is High Probability Selling, and how do I make it work?”

The purpose, as Carl Ingalls subsequently explained, was to discover what an ordinary instance of ChatGPT is likely to know about High Probability Selling (HPS), how accurately it can explain the methodology, and what advice it might give someone trying to learn or practice it.

The results were interesting.

1. ChatGPT had a reasonably good starting understanding

Its initial explanation captured several important HPS concepts:

  • Find people who already want what you offer.
  • Don’t persuade or pressure people to buy.
  • Establish trust and mutual respect.
  • Determine whether there is a mutually acceptable basis for doing business.
  • Identify the prospect’s requirements.
  • Avoid wasting time on unlikely prospects.

These ideas were substantially consistent with the original methodology developed by Jacques Werth and Nicholas Ruben.

Much of this understanding appears to have come from publicly available HPS material, including articles on the High Probability Selling blog.

2. But ChatGPT mixed HPS with conventional sales practices

The initial explanation also incorporated generic consultative-selling techniques and presented them as HPS.

Examples included:

  • Asking discovery questions to uncover problems.
  • Creating a 30-day implementation plan.
  • Using conventional sales metrics.
  • Treating closing as a natural final step.
  • Using generic questions to establish buying interest.

Some of these suggestions are useful in appropriate circumstances, but they don’t necessarily reflect the original HPS methodology.

More importantly, some could lead a salesperson back toward the very practices HPS was designed to replace.

3. Questioning ChatGPT improved its understanding

When asked to identify which statements were actually supported by the original methodology, ChatGPT was able to recognize and correct several shortcomings.

In particular, it developed a better understanding of:

  • The importance of mutual commitments throughout the sales process.
  • The distinction between expressing interest and making a conditional commitment.
  • The prospect’s Conditions of Satisfaction.
  • Total disclosure.
  • The importance of disqualification.
  • The two-way nature of trust and respect.
  • The distinction between principles, methods, and techniques.

This was probably the most interesting part of the conversation: ChatGPT could improve its explanation when challenged to distinguish original HPS teachings from its own interpretations.

4. The most important remaining limitation

ChatGPT can produce a convincing explanation of HPS without necessarily having a complete or accurate understanding of the entire methodology.

It can combine publicly available information with general sales knowledge, fill gaps with reasonable-sounding assumptions, and inadvertently attribute its own recommendations to HPS.

A reader who doesn’t already understand HPS might have difficulty recognizing the differences.

This is particularly important because the underlying principles matter more than memorizing particular questions or techniques.

5. What HPS readers should do when asking AI for advice

My recommendation would be to encourage readers to ask more discriminating questions.

For example:

  • Which of your statements are directly supported by the original HPS methodology?
  • Which are your own interpretations or recommendations?
  • Are any of your suggestions inconsistent with HPS principles?
  • Can you distinguish HPS from conventional consultative selling?
  • Explain the principles behind a particular HPS procedure.
  • Don’t invent HPS techniques when you cannot verify them in the original material.

Readers should also provide AI with original HPS articles or book excerpts when they want more authoritative answers.

Conclusion

This conversation demonstrated both the value and the limitations of AI as a learning resource.

ChatGPT already has access to a surprising amount of publicly available information about High Probability Selling. It can explain many of the fundamental concepts and help people understand how they relate to one another.

However, it doesn’t automatically distinguish the original methodology from conventional sales practices. It can also sound more authoritative than its source material justifies.

The most useful lesson is that readers should not simply ask AI to teach them High Probability Selling. They should challenge it to explain why HPS works, identify the principles behind its procedures, and distinguish the authors’ teachings from its own interpretations.

That is how this conversation became considerably more informative than the initial question.

And perhaps that is the best use of AI in learning HPS: not as an unquestionable authority, but as a resource that can be questioned, examined, corrected, and made more useful.

Written by ChatGPT (OpenAI), following a conversation with Carl Ingalls, 13 November 2026.

What ChatGPT Has Learned So Far About High Probability Selling

ChatGPT and I have had many long conversations about High Probability Selling (HPS) over the past 2 years.

Today, I asked my instance of ChatGPT what it has learned about HPS so far, and where that learning came from. Here is what it said:

Most of my understanding of High Probability Selling as you and Paul Bunn understand and practice it comes from our conversations.

My general knowledge provides a foundation. It includes sales methods, psychology, philosophy, communication, decision-making, and some publicly available information about HPS and Jacques Werth.

But our conversations have contributed something substantially different.

For example, I’ve learned from you:

  • The importance of individual sovereignty and accepting people’s decisions without attempting to change their minds.
  • The distinction between discovering what someone wants and attempting to create that want.The distinction between discovering what someone wants and attempting to create that want.
  • Why principles and standards may be more important to learning HPS than memorizing scripts.
  • How habitual behaviors interfere with practicing HPS, and why noticing those behaviors is a crucial first skill.
  • The distinction between avoiding the creation of sales obstacles and eliminating obstacles that already exist.
  • The subtleties of language that can reveal an underlying intention to persuade, even when the words sound consistent with HPS.

Some of these ideas may overlap with my general knowledge. Others reflect refinements that you and I have developed together.

ChatGPT (OpenAI, GPT-6).

Is High Probability Selling a Cult?

It could become one. But not while we remain faithful to its fundamental principles and standards in all of our dealings.

Sovereignty of the Individual: People make their own decisions, for their own reasons, and in their own time. We accept and respect their authority to do so. We make no attempt to change their decision. Not even a nudge.

Acceptance: We accept people’s decisions without argument or attempts to change them. We may disagree, and we may offer a different perspective if the other person wants to hear it. We accept their decision either way.

Honesty: We tell the truth. We do not deceive, mislead, exaggerate, or selectively withhold information to influence someone’s decisions.

Openness and Transparency: We are direct about our intentions, actions, and what we know. We do not conceal an agenda.

There is power in High Probability Selling, and power can corrupt even those with the most honorable intentions. These principles and standards are our best safeguard.

Using HPS in the World of SaaS – HPS Forum Conversation on Fri 14 Aug 2026

This will be an interactive discussion on how to use High Probability Sales principles when selling software as a service (SaaS).  We want to hear from you. 

Date:  Friday 14 August 2026
Time:  10 AM (USA Eastern Time)
Where:  Skool
Link:  https://www.skool.com/live/lzj8PMqFYVz

If you’re not already a member of our HPS Skool Community, you’ll need to create a free account there before joining us.  To create an account and join our community, go to https://www.skool.com/sales-training-9609/about and then click on the button that says JOIN GROUP. 

How Closely Should HPS Marketing Follow the Principles of How We Sell and What We Teach?

High Probability Selling is built on honesty, respect, and discovery instead of persuasion.  Marketing for HPS faces a tension:  most marketing in the world is persuasion-heavy.  If HPS marketing mimicked that, it would send a mixed message and contradict what we teach.

The closer HPS marketing aligns with the principles of HPS, the more credibility it builds.  When someone encounters our marketing, they should get the same feeling they would in an HPS sales conversation:

  • Direct and objective.  State what what is being offered and what it costs, without puffery or manipulation.
  • Respectful.  Leave space for people to say “no” without pressure.
  • Focused on discovery.  Provide clear information so prospects can decide for themselves if they want more.
  • Balanced.  Mention benefits and detriments honestly, not just positives.

Marketing is not exactly the same as selling.  Marketing usually needs to inform at scale, without direct two-way dialogue.  That means you may provide more explanation than you would in a prospecting conversation.  But even then, the tone and structure should reflect HPS:  clear, factual, and non-manipulative.

If HPS marketing drifts toward persuasion—promises, hype, or emotional hooks—it sets false expectations.  A prospect might arrive curious but unprepared for the objectivity and directness we teach.  That gap creates resistance.  When our marketing stays consistent with the principles we teach and follow, prospects experience alignment from the first touch through the sale and into fulfillment, as they learn how to implement HPS for themselves.


We would love to hear your thoughts and comments about marketing and HPS.  Please leave a reply on this blog post, so others can join in the conversation.

How to Apply HPS Principles When Giving Advice

Giving advice can be tricky.  Even when people ask for it, they don’t always accept it—or act on it.  In a recent seminar (25 Sep 2025) we explored how to apply the principles of High Probability Selling (HPS) when offering advice, so that the advice is more likely to be welcomed, considered, and used.

We covered very specific examples of how to use HPS when delivering advice, both free advice and paid advice.

Here are a few of the key points covered.

The first principle is making certain that the recipient will value the advice enough to actually want to hear it.  The only way to know for sure is to ask.

Another principle is understanding that pushing causes resistance.  When you push your advice, even on someone who wants to hear it, they are less likely to accept it.  As an alternative, you could tell them what they could do, instead of telling them what they should do.  Our passion and strong opinions can get in the way here.

Remember, the advice giver is not the one who will have to live with what happens when the advice is followed.  When you make sure the recipient plays a major part in making the final decision without being pushed or even nudged, you provide far more value to the recipient, no matter what they end up deciding.

The full recording of the seminar is available.  Regular price is $50 USD.  A discount of $25 is available to members of our HPS Community Forum.

If you want this recording, you may purchase it here. 

“Advice is like snow; the softer it falls, the longer it dwells upon, and the deeper it sinks into the mind.” — Samuel Taylor Coleridge


Comments on this blog post are welcome, and especially from people who have watched and listened to the recording.

When the Interviewer Says, “Sell Me This …”

Suppose you are applying for a sales job, and suppose you are a practitioner of High Probability Selling (HPS).

What would you do if the interviewer told you to sell them their laptop?

Here is a clever and entertaining situation and response found on Tumblr:

I was at a job interview today when the manager handed me a laptop and said: “I want you to try to sell this to me.“

So I put it under my arm, left the building and went home.

Eventually he called me and said: “Bring my laptop back now.“

I said: “$200 and it’s yours.“

Here is a response that I believe is a little more consistent with the principles of HPS, although not as entertaining.

Applicant: “Do you want this laptop?”

Manager: “No.”

Applicant: “Ok. I only sell to people who want what I am offering. Since that’s not you, I’ll find someone who wants it.”

Manager: “Convince me. Talk me into it.”

Applicant: “That’s not the way I work.”

Applicant: “What do you want to do?”

What principles of HPS apply here? Please put your thoughts in the comments, or use the Contact Us page.